Shows by played in

August 2025: 16 | 16 | 28 | 31 | 31
September 2025: 12 | 14 | 14 | 17 | 17 | 19 | 20 | 23 | 24 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 30
October 2025: 02 | 03 | 04 | 05 | 09 | 10 | 11 | 18 | 18 | 24 | 25 | 25 | 25
November 2025: 02 | 07 | 08 | 14 | 15 | 21 | 22 | 25 | 26
December 2025: 08 | 12 | 13 | 17 | 19 | 20 | 20 | 27
January 2026: 13 | 15

No known setlist.

No known setlist.

Show Notes: This show featured Cotter on drums.

Set 1: Them Changes, Nothing From Nothing, Ain’t No Crime, Up On Cripple Creek[1], Ain’t No Bread in the Breadbox[2], Golden Age[3], Christmas In L.A.[4], Jealous Guy[4], Rock Steady[5], Hold Me[4]

Set 2: All That You Dream[6], Eat That Question, Whole Lotta Love[7], Whipping Post[8], Stormy Monday[9], New Speedway Boogie[9], Loose Lucy[9]

Encore: Loving Cup[10]

Coach's Notes:
    [1] With Kiran Edwards on keys and vocals and Jessica Leone on vocals.
    [2] With Jake Brownstein on guitar, Kiran Edwards on keys and vocals, and Jessica Leone on vocals.
    [3] With Jake Brownstein on guitar.
    [4] With Tema Siegel on vocals.
    [5] With Tema Siegel and Jess Leone on vocals.
    [6] With Jess Leone on vocals.
    [7] With Nico Suave on vocals.
    [8] With Nico Suave on vocals, Lara Cwass on guitar, and Evan Barker on bass.
    [9] With Lara Cwass on guitar and Jess Leone on vocals.
    [10] With Lara Cwass on guitar, Kiran Edwards on keys, Nico Suave on vocals, and Jess Leone on vocals.

Show Notes: This show was billed as "Cotter's Jingle Jamboree" and featured Mike Goodman, Brian Murray, and Jeremy Kaplan.

Opening Band(s): Ross Bogan’s Wolf Mask ft. Jake Brownstein

Set 1: Sunny Day[1], Show Me[1]

Set 2: Poseidon[2]

Coach's Notes:
    [1] With Peter on keys.
    [2] With Peter on guitar.

Coach's Notes:
    [1] Unfinished. With Yeti teases from Peter.
    [2] New name for “Your House.”
    [3] With Star Wars Theme tease from Seth.
    [4] With Jeff Engborg on keys.
    [5] Red Hot Chili Peppers. With Greg Ormont on vocals and Ultimate Riff from Peter and Ethan.

Show Notes: This was an opening set for Pigeons Playing Ping Pong.

No known setlist.

Show Notes: This show featured Cotter on drums.

No known setlist.

Coach's Notes:
    [1] Traditional. FTP. With Providence College Choir on vocals.
    [2] With Providence College Choir on vocals.
    [3] Fast version.
    [4] Unfinished.
    [5] Brian Eno & David Byrne. FTP.
    [6] The Band. FTP. With Stuart Bogie on saxophone, Dave Nelson on trombone, and Jordan McLean on trumpet.
    [7] With Stuart Bogie on saxophone, Dave Nelson on trombone, and Jordan McLean on trumpet.
    [8] Unfinished. With Stuart Bogie on saxophone, Dave Nelson on trombone, and Jordan McLean on trumpet.
    [9] Unfinished. With Stuart Bogie on saxophone, Dave Nelson on trombone, and Jordan McLean on trumpet and Workin' Day and Night teases.
    [10] With DJ Marb Menthols on turntables.
    [11] Caravan Palace. With Stuart Bogie on saxophone, Dave Nelson on trombone, and Jordan McLean on trumpet and Cantina Band tease.
    [12] With Stuart Bogie on saxophone, Dave Nelson on trombone, Jordan McLean on trumpet, and Barnaby Glimpse on drums with Cotter. Additional vocal outro featuring the Providence College Choir.

Show Notes: The show began where the previous show left off - Rick walked up on stage and turned on the light as a choir began to sing a drone off stage. The choir then joined after the first chorus. During Marb House, a UV Dance Party commenced with characters dancing on stage and painting all the set props with UV paint. During the encore all of the characters and puppets appeared as well as two aerialists. There was also a balloon drop and confetti during Dramophone. The show ended with the veil opening back up, after the veil sequence, the characters, puppets, choir, and band had vanished. This show was part of Goosemas XII.

Coach's Notes:
    [1] Caravan Palace. FTP. With Stuart Bogie on woodwinds.
    [2] With Stuart Bogie on woodwinds.
    [3] The Shouting Matches. FTP. With Stuart Bogie on woodwinds.
    [4] Pink Floyd. FTP. With Stuart Bogie on woodwinds.
    [5] Unfinished. With Stuart Bogie on woodwinds.
    [6] Radiohead. FTP. With Stuart Bogie on woodwinds.
    [7] With Dueling Banjos tease.
    [8] Gregory Alan Isakov. FTP. With Stuart Bogie on woodwinds and no Cotter.
    [9] Neil Young. FTP. Rick & Peter duet that ended with Rick solo.

Show Notes: Moby was played for the first time since February 13, 2025 (58 shows). Before the show, creepy music played and technical difficulties ensued marked by Loomis calling over the PA, suddenly the entire crowd was sent through the veil much like the 4 lads from the promo video. Upon landing in a new world Barnaby Glimpse welcomed his new friends to his Show Upon Time. Following his opening monologue, the band kicked into a Menagerie set marked by animal balloons, animal puppets and animal performers. Carnies also passed out Goose branded Animal Crackers. After Animal, Barnaby reappeared on stage for a brief monologue. During the encore, members slowly left the stage, Cotter first after Jed, then Stu and Trevor after Master & a Hound. Peter left during Sugar Mountain. At the end of the song, Rick shut off the lamp on his rig and left the stage.

Coach's Notes:
    [1] Slow, melodic version. Unfinished.
    [2] Father John Misty.
    [3] Peter Gabriel.
    [4] Otis Day & The Knights.

Show Notes: This was a private show for the Music Club of NYC.

No known setlist.

Show Notes: This show featured Cotter on drums.

No known setlist.

Show Notes: This show featured Cotter on drums.

No known setlist.

No known setlist.

No known setlist.

Show Notes: This show featured Cotter on drums.

No known setlist.

Show Notes: This show featured Cotter on drums.

No known setlist.

Show Notes: This show was a recreation of Phish 7/26/97 and featured Cotter on a second drum set.

Set 1: Beauty of My Dreams, Wolfman's Brother > Maze, Water in the Sky, Bathtub Gin > Makisupa Policeman > AC/DC Bag

Set 2: Chalk Dust Torture -> Taste -> Ya Mar -> Drums > Ghost > Character Zero

Encore: Theme From the Bottom

Show Notes: This show was a recreation of Phish 7/25/97 and featured Cotter on a second drum set for the second set and encore.

Coach's Notes:
    [1] Unfinished.
    [2] Rockwell. FTP.
    [3] Tears For Fears.
    [4] First verse only.
    [5] With You Spin Me Round (Like A Record) teases.
    [6] Harold Melvin & The Blue Notes.

Show Notes: This show was part of the Suwannee Hulaween festival. Mad World was played for the first time since September 20, 2024 (89 shows).

No known setlist.

Show Notes: This show was part of Brewster River Jamfest.

No known setlist.

Show Notes: This show was part of Brewster River Jamfest.

No known setlist.

Show Notes: This show was part of Brewster River Jamfest.

No known setlist.

No known setlist.

Show Notes: This show was a part of the Golden Road Festival and featured Cotter alongside Tom Hamilton, Aron Magner, Jake Brownstein, and special guests.

No known setlist.

Show Notes: This show was a part of the Golden Road Festival and featured Cotter on drums.

Set 1: Aqui Como Alla, Keep Your Eyes Open, Funky Junk, Chank, Foots, National Anthem, Jan Jan, Cinnamon Girl

Set 2: Sabotage, Trouble Every Day, Bake, Fixin' To Die, Whipping Post, Sweet Leaf, The Music Never Stopped, Loving Cup

Show Notes: This show featured Rob Compa, Justin Mazer, Leon Campos, Chuck Jones, and Brian Murray.

Set 1: Flood in Franklin Park, Norwegian Wood (This Bird Has Flown), Camelus, Keep Your Eyes Open, Bake, Mr. Charlie, Cinnamon Girl, In Memory of Elizabeth Reed

Set 2: Foots, Fixin' To Die, The Music Never Stopped, Whole Lotta Love, Whipping Post, Sweet Leaf, Rat Salad

Show Notes: This show featured Rob Compa, Justin Mazer, Leon Campos, Jack Vignone, and Brian Murray.

No known setlist.

Show Notes: This was a fully improvised show featuring Brian Murray, Justin Mazer, Leon Campos, and Josh Weinstein.

Show Notes: This show was part of the RISE Festival.

Coach's Notes:
    [1] Unfinished.
    [2] Dead or Alive.

Coach's Notes:
    [1] Prince.
    [2] Foster The People.
    [3] Arcade Fire.
    [4] With Chank teases from Rick and Peter.
    [5] Kenny Loggins.
    [6] With The Lion Sleeps Tonight quotes.

Show Notes: Wake Up was played for the first time since June 25, 2022 (256 shows).

Coach's Notes:
    [1] Slow, melodic version. Unfinished.
    [2] FTP. Ween.
    [3] 80s synth version. With Welcome to Delta jam.
    [4] With Mercy, Mercy, Mercy tease from Peter.
    [5] Unfinished.
    [6] FTP electric.
    [7] Nina Simone.
    [8] Bobby Blue Bland.

Coach's Notes:
    [1] Chick Corea.
    [2] David Gray.
    [3] Unfinished.
    [4] Kylie Minogue.

Show Notes: Spain was played for the first time since June 25, 2024 (103 shows). Can’t Get You Out Of My Head was played for the first time since October 26, 2024 (73 shows).

Coach's Notes:
    [1] Fast version. Unfinished.
    [2] Creedence Clearwater Revival.
    [3] Grateful Dead.
    [4] Tom Waits.

Show Notes: This was a private show for the Music Club of Charlotte.

Coach's Notes:
    [1] Father John Misty.
    [2] Unfinished.
    [3] John Phillips.
    [4] Bob Seger & The Silver Bullet Band.
    [5] With Max Moore on guitar and vocals and Charles Eastman on keys and vocals.

Opening Band(s): Penelope Road

Coach's Notes:
    [1] Kate Bush.
    [2] Fat Freddy’s Drop.
    [3] Unfinished.

Show Notes: Loose Ends was played for the first time since November 12, 2024 (59 shows).

Opening Band(s): Penelope Road

Coach's Notes:
    [1] Jam only. Finished version from 9/23/25.
    [2] Unfinished.
    [3] The Beatles.
    [4] Jim James. With Jim James on guitar and vocals.
    [5] The Band. with Jim James on guitar and vocals.

Coach's Notes:
    [1] Slow, melodic version. Unfinished.
    [2] Spoon.
    [3] Walter Murphy.
    [4] Unfinished.
    [5] With.
    [6] Nina Simone.

Show Notes: A Fifth Of Beethoven was played for the first time since June 11, 2024 (108 shows).

Coach's Notes:
    [1] The Who.
    [2] Future Islands. FTP.
    [3] Harold Melvin & The Blue Notes.

Coach's Notes:
    [1] Sergio Mendes.
    [2] Kenny Loggins.
    [3] Unfinished.
    [4] Fast version. Unfinished.
    [5] Eddy Grant.
    [6] Dead or Alive.

Show Notes: Make The Move was played for the first time since June 20, 2024 (100 shows).

Show Notes: This was a co-headlining show with Mt. Joy.

Set 1: Ocean Man[1], Astrovan[1], What’s Up[1]

Coach's Notes:
    [1] With Rick on guitar and vocals, Peter on keys, Trevor on bass, and Cotter on drums.

Show Notes: This was a co-headlining show with Goose.

No known setlist.

Show Notes: This was an after-party for Goose at Waterfront Park and featured Cotter sitting in.

Soundcheck: Jam, Iguana Song, Royal, Atlas (x3)

Coach's Notes:
    [1] The Wood Brothers. With Kat Wright on vocals, Bob Wagner on guitar, and Josh Weinstein on bass.
    [2] Unfinished.
    [3] Otis Day & The Knights.

Coach's Notes:
    [1] Slow, melodic version. Unfinished.
    [2] The Band.
    [3] Peter Gabriel.

Set 1: The Maker[1]

Coach's Notes:
    [1] With Rick on guitar and vocals.

Coach's Notes:
    [1] With Jeff Coffin on saxophone and Rashawn Ross on trumpet.

Show Notes: This was an opening set for Dave Matthews Band.

Soundcheck: Into the Myst, Atlas, Jam

Coach's Notes:
    [1] Slow, melodic version. Unfinished.
    [2] The National.
    [3] Unfinished.
    [4] Otis Day & The Knights.

Show Notes: This show was the University of Iowa's Fall Welcome Concert.

No known setlist.

Show Notes: Rick sat in on guitar for the second half of the Dead House set.

Coach's Notes:
    [1] Fast version.
    [2] Unfinished.


Powered by Songfish